www.nacctep.org/briefs


AUGUST 2004

VOLUME 1

ISSUE 7

 

Inside This Issue

Hispanics Face College Pitfalls

NCLB Not Mentioned in Governor's Races

Data on Charter Schools Examined More Closely

Performance Based Accountability Measures Implemented in All 50 States

The New England Compact

Quick Links

State by State...

This Policy Brief is developed by the National Center for Teacher Education of the Maricopa Community Colleges.

Please direct any comments or submissions to:
Dr. Cheri St. Arnauld
Executive Director,
National Association of Community College Teacher Education Programs/ National Director of Teacher Education Programs

2411 W. 14th Street
Tempe, AZ 85281
Phone: 480.731.8726
Fax: 480.731.8786

FEEDBACK

NACCTEP is very interested in your feedback and ideas! Please email us with topics or issues you would like to see discussed in future briefs.

 

ARCHIVES

Volume 1, Issue 1

Volume 1, Issue 2

Volume 1, Issue 3

Special Edition Policy Brief

Volume 1, Issue 5

Volume 1, Issue 6

Volume 1, Issue 7



WELCOME

Welcome to the Policy Brief. The purpose of this brief is to provide a resource for teacher education professionals, administrators and students from which teacher preparation, recruitment, retention and renewal programs and policies can be developed.

Hispanics Face College Pitfalls

According to a new national study entitled "Latino Youth Finishing College: The Role of Selective Pathways," by the Pew Hispanic Center, Latinos do not graduate as often or as quickly as Anglo students and many attend less-demanding schools that may impede their graduation track.

The study indicates that Hispanic youths are confronted with challenges that Anglo youths are not.  These include delayed entry to college, greater financial responsibility for family members, living with family while in college rather than in campus housing, and the tendency to attend secondary institutions that are less selective. It finds that the gap in white/Hispanic bachelor's degree completion could be substantially closed if these well-prepared Latino youth attended the same kind of colleges as similarly prepared whites and graduated at the same rate.

A few of the report’s key findings include :

  • Among the best prepared young college students, nearly 60 percent of Latinos attend non-selective colleges and universities, in comparison to 52 percent of white students.
  • In attainment of a bachelor's degree, disparities are evident across the spectrum of higher education. For example, white youth beginning at community colleges are nearly twice as likely as Hispanic youth beginning at community colleges to finish a bachelor’s degree.
  • Comparing the best prepared white and Latino college students at non-selective colleges and universities, 81 percent of whites complete a bachelor’s degree and 57 percent of Latinos.
  • Highly qualified Latinos enroll at top schools at the same rate as their white peers.
  • Among two-year college entrants that are “minimally qualified” for college, 16 percent of whites finished a bachelor’s degree versus only 7 percent of Hispanics.

Read the full report here.

Source: Pew Hispanic Center (www.pewhispanic.org)

BACK TO TOP

 

NCLB Not Mentioned in Governor's Races


According to an article in Stateline.org, new education proposals are rare in the country's 11 governor's races - issues are more focused on struggles with school spending, job creation, health care and other economic issues. 

The only campaign debating the No Child Left Behind law is in Utah
where the Republican nominee proposes the state opt out of the law's mandates and nearly $100 million in federal funding.

The other 10 gubernatorial campaigns have had little focus on the law, besides complaints about an under-funded mandate.
According to ASCD, the lack of debate about NCLB may stem from the public's general ignorance about the law. The latest Phi Delta Kappa/Gallup poll indicates that 68% of people know "very little" or "nothing at all" about the NCLB law.

Read more on this at Stateline.org.


Source: Stateline.org [August 24, 2004]

BACK TO TOP

 

Data on Charter Schools Examined More Closely


A recent analysis conducted by the Education Department's National Assessment of Educational Progress found that students in charter schools lagged about six months behind peers in traditional schools. The data shows that only 25% of the fourth-graders attending charter schools were proficient in reading and math, against 30% of who were proficient in reading and 32% in math, at traditional public schools.


However, some observers urge closer scrutiny of the data. After further review of the data, Andrew Rotherman, a researcher at a liberal think tank, says that the charter schools were compared to public schools, as though they had all been open a long time.  According to him, there is no way to know how most of these new schools will do over time. Additionally, he points out that when the data is controlled for race, there's no statistical difference in performance between charter and public schools.  Read more on this subject here.

Source: ASCD Smart Brief  [August 19, 2004]

BACK TO TOP

 

Performance Based Accountability Measures Implemented in All 50 States

According to the National Conference of State Legislatures, all 50 states now have implemented performance-based accountability measures that aim to improve the overall academic performance of schools. The article states that "it is not necessarily the capability of the American education system that is in question, rather it is the wide disparities that exist within the American education system that warrant attention." This achievement gap exists due to disparities that exist between race and ethnicity, economic status, geography and parental education.

A standards-based accountability system sets goals in the form of standards, assigns responsibilities for meeting those goals, and holds the system accountable for its performance. According to ASCD, in some states, policy-makers have instituted exit exams -- tests that all high school students must pass to earn a diploma. These have stirred up a great deal of controversy in the education community and beyond, particularly in states with large subgroups of students who may have difficulty passing them. Visit ECS for extensive information on accountability and assessment.

Source: ASCD SmartBrief Special Report: High Stakes Testing [August 2004].

BACK TO TOP

 

 

The New England Compact

To reduce costs and manpower, three of New England's smallest states are developing common standardized tests in a first-of-a-kind partnership in the nation.

New Hampshire, Rhode Island, and Vermont have teamed up in the effort to comply with the federal No Child Left Behind Act, which requires annual testing of students in grades 3 through 8. Interestingly, these three states also are among those nationwide that have questioned the costs of the stringent NCLB requirements.

Last year, the New Hampshire Legislature cut $3 million from its state testing program.  This cut forced the state Department of Education to eliminate the writing, science, and social studies components of its assessment tests this year.

The partnership, known as the New England Compact, will test reading and math exams this fall, followed by testing of more than 208,000 students in grades 3 through 8 starting in December 2005. Rhode Island officials estimate they will save $5 million through the combined effort and state education officials for New Hampshire and Vermont say they could reduce per-student testing costs from $22 to approximately $12.

Peter McWalters, Rhode Island's education commissioner said he does not see a movement developing towards a single national test. The three states are also developing future combined tests for science and a high school level exam.

Source: ASCD SmartBrief Special Report II: High Stakes Testing [August 2004]; The Boston Globe [June 22, 2004].

BACK TO TOP

 

QUICK LINKS

According to a report from the American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education, the ultimate goal of education reform should be the creation of a seamless, P-16 education pipeline. The report says all early childhood educators should have at least a bachelor's degree in early childhood education and those teaching 4- to 8-year-old children should be certified.  Read more here.

There is an emerging track record of success in using key elements of standards based reform to raise student achievement, a new report finds. The report seeks to distill the lessons learned from efforts in Massachusetts and Washington to make academic standards and high-stakes assessments successful.  Read more here.

See a summary of state policy developments that ECS has tracked over the past month or see a summary of the current calendar year.

BACK TO TOP

 

STATE BY STATE. . .

Chicago's Test Scores Higher
Chicago’s test scores are up this year. Nearly three-quarters of both elementary and high schools improved composite test scores. School officials predict that more schools will meet the standards under No Child Left Behind and claim that Chicago is at the forefront of a transformation in urban public education.  [Source: Education Innovator #30]

New Jersey Board Adopts New NCLB Policy
The Bayonne (NJ) Board of Education has adopted a new NCLB policy that strengthens the minimum qualifications for teachers, focuses on proven teaching strategies, and includes the integration of technology in both elementary and secondary schools.  [Source: Education Innovator #30]   

Percentage of Teachers in Louisiana at 10-Year High
Superintendent of Education Cecil Picard announced that the percentage of certified teachers in Louisiana is at a 10-year high and at the same time, high school students’ scores on the ACT and national rankings of the state’s accountability program are at an all-time high. One factor in the rise of the number of certified teachers is the availability of alternative certification programs. [Source: Education Innovator #31]   
 

BACK TO TOP